Identity Complex: The paradox of a Black White supremacist

In a shocking turn of events, the U.S. Department of Justice has cast its harshest sentence upon Henry “Enrique” Tarrio, the former leader of the Proud Boys, for his role in the violent and deadly attack on the U.S. Capitol on January 6, 2021. Tarrio, an Afro-Cuban, has been sentenced to 22 years behind bars and 36 months of supervised release for seditious conspiracy and other charges related to the insurrection. This sentence raises troubling questions about the racial disparities inherent in our justice system.

Democratic strategist Ameshia Cross, speaking to theGrio, expressed her lack of surprise at Tarrio receiving the most severe penalty among the insurrectionists charged and sentenced for their actions that fateful day. Cross pointed out that this glaring inequality is a reflection of how the American justice system has historically penalized people of color, particularly Black and brown individuals, with harsher sentencing guidelines.

“It showcases that the American justice system works the way the American justice system always has – by penalizing people of color, Black and brown people, at much higher sentencing or sentencing guidelines than they do anyone else,” Cross emphasized. “This is not something that’s new in this country.”

Cross further highlighted the undeniable truth that justice has consistently favored certain colors when determining sentencing, or whether to sentence at all. This trend has been glaringly evident in the handling of the Jan. 6 rioters and orchestrators.

It’s essential to remember that Tarrio was not physically present at the U.S. Capitol during the attack. Instead, he orchestrated the assault from a hotel in Baltimore. His association with the Proud Boys became publicly known in 2020 when former President Donald Trump called them by name during a presidential debate, telling them to “stand back and stand by.” Tarrio answered this call to action, solidifying the group’s connection to Trump’s rhetoric.

Even as a white supremacist, Tarrio cannot escape the immutable truth of his own racial identity. Despite his alignment with ideologies rooted in hatred and divisiveness, he remains a Black man in a world that too often judges individuals based on the color of their skin. One must wonder if, during his time behind bars, will he have moments of reflection. As he contemplates his choices, perhaps he listens to the haunting words of Soul II Soul’s “Back to Life,” with the refrain “Back to life, back to reality” echoing in his mind. It’s a question worth pondering: Can one find their way back to a more inclusive reality after embracing such divisive beliefs?

Cross explained that individuals like Tarrio of Afro-Cuban descent can find themselves caught up in the allure of white supremacist organizations due to a dangerous mix of factors, including “groupthink” and a desire to distance themselves from their own racial identity.

“To be a white supremacist, you don’t have to be white,” she asserted. “You can believe and posture yourself outside of the group that you look exactly like…because you have distanced yourself far from them.”

Two days before the insurrection, Tarrio was arrested for setting a Black Lives Matter flag on fire outside a church in Washington, D.C. His expulsion from the city prevented him from participating in the U.S. Capitol attack.

During his trial, Tarrio’s legal team attempted to portray him as a patriot who had lost his way, deserving of a more lenient sentence. However, these efforts were ultimately unsuccessful.

Stephen Piggott, program director at Western States Center, an organization that monitors anti-democracy and white nationalist groups, noted that while justice must prevail, incarcerating Proud Boys members will not eliminate America’s deep-rooted issue with white supremacy, according to theGrio. Piggott stressed that many of those who participated in the January 6 attack were not formal members of such groups but were radicalized through online content or influenced by the former president’s words.

“When you look at what’s going on the ground right now and the kind of white nationalist movement in the United States, I don’t think that the DOJ’s efforts to hold domestic terrorists accountable has really slowed down the activity of any of these groups or individuals,” Piggott lamented.

The case of Enrique Tarrio serves as a glaring example of the systemic injustices that persist in America’s criminal justice system. While this sentence may seem like an attempt to address the racism and white supremacy that were on full display on January 6, it is evident that even an Afro-Cuban man can find himself on the wrong end of a system that perpetuates inequality, as Jay-Z once remarked, “I’m not Black, I’m OJ – ‘yea okay’.”